Scottish Soccer Affiliation chief of referees Willie Collum believes Celtic and Dundee United ought to have been awarded penalty kicks following VAR evaluations at first of the season.
Colum additionally criticized referee Matthew McDermid’s physique language earlier than Rangers striker Cyril Desers scored within the win over St Johnstone at Hampden Park final month.
Former referee Collum, who took cost of Scotland this summer time, defined a few of the large choices made through the first 4 weeks of the season in his new month-to-month present ‘The VAR Assessment’ on the SFA YouTube channel.
Please use Chrome browser for a extra handy video participant
Highlights from Celtic’s 4-0 victory over Kilmarnock within the Scottish Premiership
He recalled the controversial incident at Celtic Park when Hoops ahead Kyogo Furuhashi touched the ball previous Robby McCrorie earlier than squaring off with Kilmarnock The goalkeepers collided.
Referee Don Robertson and the VAR official concluded that “the goalkeeper simply magnified himself”, however Collum stated: “We felt it was the incorrect choice. We’ve got guided the referee and the VAR officer {that a} penalty ought to have been awarded right here.
Collum stated McCrory’s habits was “reckless” after Kyogo knocked the ball down
“It was an surprising free-kick and the best way the ball was lower in was a shock to the referee, who struggled to search out an angle across the wall to get the fitting view.”
“The Celtic participant was clearly forward and touched the ball previous the goalkeeper and we imagine the goalkeeper’s habits was reckless. An off-field evaluation ought to have been requested and the referee requested to return to the monitor.”
Colum additionally highlighted the incident when referee David Dickinson denied Dundee United’s penalty request after the ball struck Dundee defender Luke Graham on the arm.
Within the derby match between Dundee United and Dundee, referee David Dickinson didn’t award a penalty kick
“It was a handball miss,” Collum stated. “The ball got here first from distant, by the nook.
“The Dundee participant, when he jumped, his arms have been in an unnatural place and he did not collide along with his opponent.”
Please use Chrome browser for a extra handy video participant
Highlights from the Dundee derby because the Scottish Premiership season begins
Collum additionally cleared away a controversial aim for Rangers in opposition to St Johnstone when Desers scored after dispossessing Saints defender Jack Saunders.
Some gamers and head coach Craig Levine stated their defenders have been distracted by McDermid’s name for a Saints free kick.
Collum revealed {that a} recording confirmed that the referee didn’t blow his whistle earlier than the aim.
St Johnstone declare whistle was blown earlier than Rangers scored in Carabao Cup tie, however audio evaluation proves in any other case
“The referee most likely did not present good physique language right here,” Collum stated. “When he was challenged, his physique language was edging in the direction of the free-kick.
“However he delayed the whistle appropriately, he communicated it appropriately so VAR knew what he was going to do if a aim was scored and when the ball hit the online he blew the whistle and he thought it was a one-time Defensive free company – Kick.
“VAR checked and realized there was no foul dedicated by the Rangers participant, in order that they beneficial an on-field evaluation.
“Aside from the physique language, the fitting course of was adopted and in the end the fitting choice was made.”
Sky Sports activities dwell protection of Scottish Premier League and SWPL
Sky Sports activities – From 2024/25, Sky Sports activities’ flagship channel will broadcast as much as 60 Scottish Premiership matches, together with Sky Sports activities Soccer and Sky Sports activities Predominant Occasion, in addition to no less than 5 SWPL matches.
Sky Sports activities Information – Scottish followers can watch Sky Sports activities Information (channel 409)’s rolling editorial protection of the Premier League and SWPL all season lengthy, 24 hours a day, 7 days per week.
sky sports activities digital – Comply with all the most recent from Scottish soccer on SkySports.com and app, together with unique options and interviews, plus devoted dwell weblog protection, Sky Sports activities dwell match footage and free highlights.
Sky Sports activities Social – Along with protection and visibility of the league throughout all of Sky Sports activities’ main social media channels, bespoke X Page @ScotlandSky will proceed to be the house of all Scottish soccer content material on Sky Sports activities.
Highlights—— Tune in each week for Sky Sports activities Soccer’s unique protection of Premier League matches.
Sky Sports activities is the house of home soccer within the UK and Eire, providing motion from the Scottish Premiership, Scottish Ladies’s Premier League, Premier League, WSL, EFL and extra.
Get Sky Sports activities on WhatsApp!
Now you can begin receiving messages and alerts on the most recent breaking sports activities information, evaluation, in-depth options and movies from our devoted WhatsApp channel!
Be taught extra right here…
